Zum Hauptinhalt

Rail Transport System

Website: Hamburg Open Online University
Kurs: MoGoLo - Mobility of Goods and Logistics Systems
Buch: Rail Transport System
Gedruckt von: Gast
Datum: Sonntag, 24. November 2024, 16:17

Beschreibung

In this section you will learn more about the rail transport system and its different elements goods, trains, railways and railway stations. This topic follows the structure of the conceptual system model of transport and traffic.

1. Introduction

In this section, you will learn more about the rail transport system. After the activities, the goods, that are transported by rail are presented to you. Rail transport requires trains, railways and railway stations, so you will also learn more about those elements. To summarize the section of rail transport, some advantages and disadvantages of the rail transport system will be presented.

The figure "Rail system model" shows the structure of the content of this topic.

Mindmap
Rail system model von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

On the next page, the activities are presented to you. 

Literature
Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996) 

 

 

2. Activities

 

On this page, the element "Activities" is presented.

Mindmap
System model - Activities von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

As in the road transport system, goods mobility only arises when demand is stimulated by activities. The two most important points driving rail freight mobility are:

  • We as consumer drive the system.
  • The order is the steering medium.

Literature
Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996)  

 

 

3. Goods

 

The second element "Goods" of the conceptual system model relates to the goods transported by rail freight transport.

Mindmap
Rail system model - Goods von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

Typical goods that are being transported by rail are for example:

  • bulk goods, e.g. iron, steel, etc.
  • building materials as well as garbage and waste
  • liquids, mineral oil and chemical products
  • agricultural and forestry products 
  • consumer goods
  • food and therefore perishable goods which have to be temperature-controlled
  • cars and car components
  • hazardous goods 
  • heavy load transports and special transports

The relation between goods and trains is called transport. 
As in road transport, the transport volume in rail freight transport is increasing in recent years. This development will be shown to you in the following paragraph.  

 

Transport

The rail transport system plays an important role in freight transport in the United States, Russia and China. In Europe, Germany, France and Poland are the countries with the highest share of rail transport.

The transport volume and transport performance in Germany are rising, in particular due to the increase in the average transport distance from 192 km in 1992 to 331 km in 2019.  
A "cut-off" was observed in all countries in 2009 due to the global economic crisis and the recovery in the past 10 years.

On the next page, the trains needed for rail transport are presented to you.

Literature
Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Bau- und Wohnungswesen (2004): Verkehr in Zahlen 2004/2005. 33. Jahrgang, URL: https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Publikationen/G/verkehr-in-zahlen_2004-pdf.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (last access: 30.03.2022)

Bundesministerium für Verkehr und digitale Infrastruktur (2020): Verkehr in Zahlen 2020/2021. 49. Jahrgang, URL: https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Publikationen/G/verkehr-in-zahlen-2020-pdf.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (last access: 30.03.2022)

European Commission (2020): EU Transport Figures. Statistical Pocketbook 2020. URL: https://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/da0cd68e-1fdd-11eb-b57e-01aa75ed71a1.0001.03/DOC_1 (last access: 30.03.2022)

Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996)  

 

 

4. Trains

 

On this page, the element "Trains" is introduced. We will discuss different types of trains and traffic volumes. In addition, we will show you, in which different ways trains are operating. 

Mindmap
Rail system model - Trains von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

The type of the transported goods determines the decision for the type of train wagon being used. Some types of train wagons are presented to you in the following.

  • Type E: Open Top Freight Wagon
    • 2-axle and 4-axle
    • open, solid, high-resistance box wagon 
    • The wagon can be loaded from the top using mechanized loading devices.
    • This freight wagon is designed for the transport of weather-resisting bulk materials: Coal, ore, crushed rocks, etc. 
  • Type F: Open Hopper Wagon (Bulk freight wagon)
    • The wagon takes advantage of gravity to unload its contents through two pairs of bottom doors.  
    •  The self-unloading wagon is designed to transport sand, stone and other aggregate materials.
  • Type H: High Capacity Sliding Wall Wagon
    • A wagon with sliding walls, which permits easy side loading and unloading with forklifts.
    • The wagon is best suited to transport paper coils, cellulose, sawn timber, sheets of plywood and goods on palettes.
  • Type K: 2-axle Flat Wagon
    • The wagon can be loaded and unloaded from the top and via side ramps.
    • Materials can be protected against the weather by a waterproof tarpaulin. 
  • Type R: 4-axle bogie flat wagon
    • This freight wagon is designed for the transport of heavy loads of packaged materials or long loads, such as steel pipes, profiles or lumber.
  • Type S: 6-axle bogie flat wagon
    • This freight wagon is particularly for heavy loads.
  • Type T: Covered Hopper Wagon (Bulk freight wagon)
    • The wagon with swivel or roll roof and sidewall doors for heavy cargo.
  • Type T: Wagon with opening roof
    • This freight wagon is particularly suitable for weather-sensitive goods.
  • Type U: Tank wagon for forced air pressure discharge
    • This freight wagon is specifically for the transport of powdery, granular goods.
  • Type Z: Tank wagon 
    • This freight wagon is for the transport of liquids and gases.
  • Type L: Car Carrier Wagon
    • This freight wagon is designed to transport automobiles and vans.
  • Combined Transport
    • Large containers and swap bodies

Some of the presented train wagons are shown in the figure "Train wagons".
 
Trains
Train wagons von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Katharina Beck (CC BY-SA)

 

When the trains are using the railways, rail traffic is generated. Now that you've learned about the different types of wagons, let's look at the traffic and what types of traffic exist.

 

Traffic

Rail freight transport in port-hinterland traffic is dominated by block trains. These are often bulk goods transports from mining areas or agricultural regions. 
In Germany, these are usually combined transports in which containers are transported on trains. For geographical reasons, these transports in Europe and especially in Germany take place on the north-south axis. For this reason, the route loads are highest on these routes. 
In Germany - as in many other countries in the world - rail transports take place on the same infrastructure as passenger transport, but since the 1990s with separate trains. This situation often leads to capacity overload and possible transport delays on certain routes.

In Germany for example, the regulations of the German train composition standards (Güterzugbildungsvorschrift (GZV)) for freight train formation are defining the following:
  • For safety reasons, railway lines are divided into sections known as blocks.
  • Normally, only one train is permitted in each block at a time.
  • The train length influences the block allocation. 
  • The permissible maximum (total) train length is 740 metres; this corresponds to about 35 wagons (railcar length of 700 metres without driven head unit) and/or
  • a regular train has a maximum of 250 axes. Under certain conditions it is up to 252 axes or/and
  • the maximum permissible axle load is 22.5 t and/or the towing weight is 2,500 t.
Block section
Block section von Jörn Pachl (CC BY-SA)

 

The described regulations fit most of the train compositions. Sometimes, the trains do not meet the specifications and in some cases, it can have a positive impact on the traffic flow, if the trains are longer, for example. For these reasons, some exceptions exist in terms of weight or length for freight train compositions. 

Exceptions for freight train compositions are:
  • Bulk freight trains with special operational treatment up to 5,000 t.
  • November 2008: For the first time, a 1,000 m freight train ran between Oberhausen and Rotterdam (Betuwe Route in the Netherlands only for freight trains).
  • 2012: Freight trains between Padborg (DK) and Maschen (GER) with a length of 835 m (40 wagons), expanded 2016 to the Port of Hamburg (Hohe Schaar).
  • In order to operate a train that exceeds the normal dimensions, some adjustments of infrastructure and operations are required:
    • extension of passing tracks
    • adjustment of control and safety technology
    • extension of block sections
 
Main traffic corridors of rail freight transport in Germany 
The figure "Main traffic corridors of rail freight transport in Germany" shows the main traffic corridors of rail freight transport in Germany. It can be seen that a substantial part of rail freight traffic in Germany takes place in a few corridors. There is a high dependency on these main corridors and if they are not optimally managed or treated, this can have a negative impact on the growth opportunities of rail.
 
map
Main traffic corridors of rail freight transport in Germany von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Umweltbundesamt (CC BY-SA)

 

It can be seen, that the traffic is mainly on the North-South Axis and that seaport-hinterland traffic has a strong influence. The two main corridors in Germany are the:
  • Rhine Graben:  ARA-ports-Duisburg-Koblenz-Mainz-Mannheim-Karlsruhe-Basel
  • North-south route:  Hamburg-Hanover-Fulda-Würzburg-Munich-Brenner  (incl. Würzburg-Nuremberg-Passau-Vienna)

As mentioned above, different types of trains are used for rail traffic. In the following, we will discuss block trains, combined transport and single wagonload traffic.

Let’s start with the block train:

Block train
Block trains are complete trains, containing goods of one client, transported from point A to point B. The train does not need to be stopped for shunting procedures. Block trains require a large transport volume and are realized both in own-account transport and between major hubs in combined transport.
The advantages of block trains are the following:
  • Block trains are the fastest product in the rail system because of the comparatively short transport times without stopping at the marshalling yard.
  • The organization of block trains is less complex.
  • The coordination of departure and arrival times of block trains is more flexible.

In the following we will give some examples of such block trains.
  • DB Cargo AG: 
    • DBplantrain is planning the transport requirements a long time in advance, leading to a cost-effective planning. It regularly transports large volumes on fixed routes for fixed transport dates and times. 
    • DBflextrain arranges transport volumes, connections and operating times at short notice, offering a last-minute block train. Customers have maximum flexibility upon order placement.   
  • NYK Line Amsterdam-Duisburg: 
    • 80 TEU capacity per train, 6 trains per week (NYK Line)
    • Transit time: Amsterdam - Duisburg in 7 hours 
  • Trans-Sibirian container train for BMW: 
    • Regular since 2011, this new transport product enables shorter transport durations for 10,000 -12,000 km of 14-16 days. Compared to maritime transport, only half the time is needed.  
    • 75% cost advantages in comparison to air transport, but 50% above costs for maritime transport.
    • 400 trains with 35,000 containers in 2015
    • Use of customer specific trains as "dedicated company trains“
    • E.g. Trans-Siberian container train for BMW from Leipzig to Shenyang 

In contrast to block trains, rail traffic can also be operated with single wagonload traffic. 

Single wagonload traffic
In single wagonload traffic, individual wagons are loaded with goods at various locations and are then transferred to and sorted at marshalling yards. They are transported to the destination marshalling yard, where the individual wagons are separated. The customers use single wagons exclusively. Single wagonload traffic is a good option, if the customer wants to dispatch one or several wagons at the time but does not have enough quantity for a block train. It is more expensive and time-consuming than block trains because of the train composition and integration in the timetable and the multiple handlings of trains from origin to destination. 
The advantages of single wagonload traffic are: 
  • available at short notice
  • full network coverage in Europe
  • flexible management of freight wagon loading and unloading processes

Furthermore, rail transport can be organised as combined transport. 

Combined transport
Combined transport is a transport in integrated transport chains using two or more modes of transport. By using combined transport, the specific advantages of each mode of transport can be combined. 
 
There are two types of combined transport:
  • accompanied combined transport („Rollende Landstraße“ / „rolling highway“)
  • unaccompanied combined transport

For the use of the presented trains, a network of railways is necessary. This infrastructure will be presented to you on the next page.

Literature
DB Cargo AG (2022): Ganzzugverkehr: Ihre Wahl für große Mengen. URL: https://www.dbcargo.com/rail-de-de/leistungen/schienentransporte/Ganzzug (last access: 30.03.2022).

DB Netz AG (2016): Seit 2016 verkehren 835 m lange Güterzüge auch aus dem Hamburger Hafen. URL:
https://fahrweg.dbnetze.com/fahrweg-de/kunden/betrieb/laengere_gueterzuege-1393340 (last access: 30.03.2022).

DB Netz AG (2022): Nutzungsbedingungen Netz der DB Netz AG (NBN 2022). URL: https://fahrweg.dbnetze.com/fahrweg-de/kunden/nutzungsbedingungen/nutzungsbedingungen/NBN/Nutzungsbedingungen-Netz-der-DB-Netz-AG-NBN-2022-5674326?contentId=5674324 (last access: 30.03.2022).

Doll, N. (2016): Bahnverbindung Deutschland-China ist eine Erfolgsgeschichte. URL: https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article160672317/Bahnverbindung-Deutschland-China-ist-eine-Erfolgsgeschichte.html (last acces: 30.03.2022).

Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996) 

Horvath Verlag GmbH (2016): Transsiberian route: DB Cargo remains a partner of BMW. URL: http://www.oevz.com/en/news-en/transsiberian-route-db-cargo-remains-a-partner-of-bmw/ (last access: 30.03.2022).

NYK Logistics Europe Ltd.; Bruun, T.O.; Kühne School (2008): Tagesforum Internationale Transportketten.

Pachl, J. (2013): Systemtechnik des Schienenverkehrs. 7. Auflage. Springer Vieweg Verlag Wiesbaden.

UBA (2010): Schienennetz 2025/2030-Ausbaukonzeption für einen leistungsfähigen Schienengüterverkehr in Deutschland. URL: https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/461/publikationen/4005.pdf (last access: 30.03.2022).

Verkehrsrundschau (2008): Deutsche Bahn erprobt erstmals 1000-Meter-Güterzug.
URL: https://www.verkehrsrundschau.de/nachrichten/transport-logistik/deutsche-bahn-erprobt-erstmals-1000-meter-gueterzug-3020883 (last access: 30.03.2022). 

 

 

 

5. Railways

 

The next element of the conceptual system model is infrastructure. In the rail transport system, the infrastructure is called "Railways". Those railways are needed for the realization of rail traffic.

 

On this page we deal with topics such as the infrastructural structure, interoperability and technical characteristics of the railway track.

Mindmap
Rail system model - Railways von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

To provide an overview, we start with the rail infrastructure.

Rail Infrastructure
In the past, the entire railway infrastructure was private. Today the ownership structure is diverse.
The permissible axle load, the permissible speed and the permissible train length differ and are dependent on the infrastructure equipment. For historical and political reasons, the infrastructure varies greatly between regions and countries. Worldwide there are numerous track gauges, power supply systems (voltage and safety systems, width of pantographs) as well as clearance and loading gauge profiles. This makes the integration of rail services complex. 
The global railway system is dominated by six main track gauges. 
  • The 1435 millimeters gauge accounts for about 60% of the total gauge kilometers and was introduced in North America and most of Western Europe, for example.
  • The 1520 millimeters gauge accounts for about 17% of the total gauge mileage and has been introduced in Russia and some parts of Eastern Europe (Baltic States, Belarus, Ukraine).
  • The Iberian broad gauge of 1668 millimeters is unique in Western Europe and was created by averaging the Spanish (1672 millimeters) and Portuguese (1665 millimeters) broad gauge.
The longest railway infrastructure segment in the world is the Eurasian land bridge, especially along the Trans-Siberian, which is double-tracked and electrified.

Rail networks in Europe
Rail connections are not limited by national borders, so the different railway systems need to ensure a safe and seamless movement of trains.  
This so called interoperability is the ability (of the trans-European rail system) to facilitate safe and seamless movement of trains. The interoperability is hampered by differences, not only in the European rail infrastructure, for example:
  • power systems (voltage and safety systems, pantographs width),
  • track gauges,
  • clearance profiles and loading gauges profiles.

In Europe, interoperability is regulated in the Trans-European railway interoperability regulation and technical specifications (TSIs)

As you read before, the power systems are hampering the interoperability. In order to ensure a barrier-free transition between the rail networks, there are different ways to cope with the different power systems, which will be presented to you in the following.

Power system
Multi-system trains can be operated in different voltage and pantograph systems and/or using additional diesel engines:
  • Since 1960, two-and multi-system locomotives are used in transnational rail traffic, eliminating the time-consuming need to change locomotives.
  • Multi-system trains are used in particular in the high-speed rail system (e.g. Thalys operated between Cologne and Paris (1997)). 
  • Currently, the ICE 3M (406 series; "M" for multi-system capable) operates between Germany, France, Belgium and the Netherlands.
  • Since June 2007, the TGV POS runs between Paris, Eastern France and Southern Germany.

The figure "Voltage and safety systems" shows the different voltage and safety systems that are existing in different countries. The different systems are either using direct current with 1.5 kV or 3 kV or alternate current with 15 kV – 16.7 Hz or 25 kV – 50 Hz. 
 
map
Voltage- and safety systems von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Bueker (CC BY-SA)

 

 

In the figure "Pantograph width", you can see the different pantograph widths of the railway network in Europe, which is varying from 1450 mm, over 1800 mm and 1900 mm up to 2050 mm. 

map
Pantograph width von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Bueker (CC BY-SA)

 

 

In addition, a barrier-free rail network requires common technical standards such as track gauge and direction of travel, which are presented below. 

Driving direction

The figure "Driving directions" shows the different driving directions of the trains in Europe. In some countries, trains run on either the right or the left track, while in some countries, trains run on both the right and left track.

map
Driving directions von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Bueker (CC BY-SA)

 

 

Track gauges
If the track gauges are not the same size, there are several opportunities to overcome this obstacle: 

The simplest version is the transfer of passengers and transshipment of goods, for example with containers. 
Another option is the exchange of axles / bogies. This change of wheel sets is common in freight traffic to the Iberian Peninsula, as well as to Finland, while in Russia the entire bogie is changed.
Furthermore, variable gauge axles (VGA) developed by Talgo company can be used. This VGA enables trains to change their gauge width. The train slowly drives over special equipment, which unlocks the wheels and pushes them inward or outward to the needed gauge width.
The last option is the transition without modifications to the train. Minor differences in track gauges (< 15 mm) can be compensated with wider steel tires. 
 
The figure "Track gauges" gives you an overview of the different track widths/gauges in Europe. In most of Europe, the standard gauge has a width of 1435 mm. Only in some eastern countries like Russia and Finland the gauge width is 1524 mm, while in Spain and Portugal the width is 1668 mm.
 
map
 
Track gauges von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Bueker (CC BY-SA)

 

 

In Germany, the Fairy Terminal Sassnitz/Mukran is the only German port that facilitates gauge changes from standard gauge to broad gauge (Baltic States, Finland, Russia). They offer the direct loading of trucks on broad gauge wagons or / and a Gauge Change System – exclusively for freight transport – exchange of bogies.

The next two sections deal with the clearance gauge. This describes a defined vehicle boundary line that guarantees the unrestricted passage of transport vehicles and their loads.

Structure gauge
The following figure shows two structure gauges. The structure gauge is the minimum clearance outline of the wagon. The structure gauge determines the minimum height and width of tunnels and bridges required for a safe use of the railways. 
 
Illustration
Structure gauge von Volker Matthews (CC BY-SA)

 

 

While the right structure gauge (G1 profile) can be used throughout Europe, the large volume wagons on the left (G2 profile) are too big for some countries and therefore can’t be used in UK, France, Italy, Belgium and Switzerland. 

Loading gauge profile

Defines the maximum height and width for railway vehicles and loads and ensures the safe passage through bridges, tunnels and other structures. The figure shows the different loading gauges for the UK, France, Germany and the Eurotunnel. In the UK, the headroom above rail level is only 3.96 m, while the Eurotunnel has a headroom above rail level of 5.60 m.

Illustration
Loading gauge profile von Volker Matthews (CC BY-SA)
 
We just looked at the differences in the rail networks in Europe, that need to be taken into account when operating a train that passes through different countries. 
One example for a transcontinental line is the Trans-Asian railway. The interest for a long-distance rail connection between Asia and Europe was renewed in the 21st century. These connections have become known as the Trans Asian Railway, the Northern East-West Corridor, the Eurasian Land bridge, the New Silk Road or the BRI (Belt and Road Initiative). Among the numerous challenges the corridor is facing the rail system operates on two gauges, standard (1435 mm; China and most of Western Europe) and broad (1520 mm; Russia and some Scandinavian countries)

 

Literature
Academic (2022): Umsprung (Eisenbahnfahrzeug). URL: http://de.academic.ru/dic.nsf/dewiki/1432879 (last access: 30.03.2022)

Büker, T. (2018): Maps and facts on european interoperability issues. URL: http://www.bueker.net/trainspotting/voltage_map_europe.php (last access: 30.03.2022)

Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996) 

Lübcke, D., Hecht, M. (2011): Das System Bahn, 2. Auflage, Hamburg

Lumsden, K.R. (2000): Fundamentals of Logistics, Translation of selected chapters of the book “Logistikens Grunder” Göteborg, p. 49l

Matthews, V. (2007): Bahnbau. 7. Auflage, Wiesbaden

Publications Office of the European Union (2016): Directive (EU) 2016/797 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 May 2016 on the interoperability of the rail system within the European Union. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2016/797/oj (last access: 30.03.2022) 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

5.1. Quiz - Interoperability

Now that you've reached the end of this element, feel free to test yourself with this quiz question as you did in the other learning sessions:

 

Quiz: Interoperability by Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig (CC BY-SA)

 

 

 

6. Railway Stations

 

This page deals with the last element of the conceptual system model facilities. In the rail transport system, the facilities are called "Railway Stations".

Mindmap
Rail system model - Railway Stations von Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Dorothee Schielein (CC BY-SA)

 

The facilities are often intermodal, i.e. there is rail and/or waterway access. Examples are ports or freight villages. In Germany, only 2,351 company sites had direct access to rail infrastructure in 2018. At least one market participant must be a train operating company (Deutscher Bundestag, 2019).  

In the transport chain without block trains, marshalling yards are often used to form regional, national and international freight trains. Near Hamburg is the largest marshalling yard in Europe called Maschen. Some key facts about the Maschen marshalling yard:
  • In operation since 1977, underwent major modernization between 2009 and 2013.
  • Largest marshalling yard in Europe for regional, national and international freight train formation. 
  • Hub for hinterland transport of maritime ports of Hamburg and Bremerhaven as well as Scandinavia traffics.
  • Currently, around 1 million freight wagons are treated (150 trains / 3.500 wagons daily).
  • Maschen is a hump yard. 
  • Lead track on a hill (hump) that an engine pushes the cars over. Cars are uncoupled just before the hump, and roll by gravity into their destination tracks.
Railway
Marshalling yard Maschen von Deutsche Bahn (CC BY-SA)
 

 

The relation between the railway stations and the goods is called accession. 

 

Accession

The accession to the rail network is limited. While nearly every company has access to the road network, in 1994 11.742 private sides had a connection to the rail network. Afterwards, a lot of private sides decided against a private connection to the rail network, leading to a reduction of 80 % of private sides till the year 2018. In 2018, there were only 2.351 private sides left. 
 
Scale
Development of private sidings from 1994 to 2018 in Germany von Allianz pro Schiene (CC BY-SA)
 

 

This was the last element of the conceptual system model. On the next page you will find a brief summary and the advantages and disadvantages of the rail transport system. 

Literature
Allianz pro Schiene e.V. (2019): Güterverkehr-Mehr Verkehr auf die Schiene. URL: https://www.allianz-pro-schiene.de/themen/gueterverkehr/ (last access: 30.03.2022).

Deutsche Bahn AG (2019): Rangierbahnhof Maschen. URL: https://www.deutschebahn.com/pr-hamburg-de/DB-im-Norden-1/Regionale-Themen/rbf_maschen-6121248 (last access: 30.03.2022).

Deutscher Bundestag (2019): Gleisanschlüsse im deutschen Bahnnetz. Drucksache19/9305. Antwort der Bundesregierung auf die Kleine Anfrage der Abgeordneten Sabine Leidig, Dr. Gesine Lötzsch, Lorenz Gösta Beutin, weiterer Abgeordneter und der Fraktion DIE LINKE. – Drucksache 19/8731 –. URL: https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/19/093/1909305.pdf (last access: 30.03.2022).

Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996) 

 

 

 

7. Summary

Overall Rail transport is safe and reliable. The high environmental friendliness and, in addition, the high transport capacity make rail transport attractive. What speaks against it, however, are the high costs and the general inflexibility.

More advantages and disadvantages of rail transport are listed below.

Advantages
  • safe transport
  • exact time tables, reliable
  • hazardous goods permissible
  • no general driving ban on Sundays
  • heavy lift traffic handling
  • economy of scale → advantage only for block-trains and direct trains
  • high transport capacity 
  • higher single loading weight compared to trucks
  • own infrastructure → certain level of independence (e.g. no traffic jam)
  • relatively fast point to point delivery
  • if electrified, best ecological performance compared to other transport modes
  • low energy consumption per tkm, based on transported unit 
  • opportunities for automation

Disadvantages
  • no complete coverage and in most countries reduction of the track network
  • inflexible operations through binding timetable 
  • inflexible due to high expenditures of time and costs for the preparation and implementation of transportation
  • capital-intensive set-up, operation and maintenance costs
  • high external costs
  • exclusion of certain dangerous goods
  • no seamless interfaces between competing railway networks under separate ownership (interoperability and non-discrimination)
Now you know the most important things about the rail transport system. If you are interested in other modes of transport too, feel free to check our other topics inland waterway transport system, maritime transport system, air transport system and road transport system.

Literature
Nuhn, H.; Hesse, M. (2006): Verkehrsgeographie, Schöningh Verlag, Paderborn

Schulte, C. (1991): Logistik. Wege zur Optimierung des Material- und Informationsflusses. Verlag Franz Vahlen, München. S. 64-65

Wannenwetsch, H. (Hrsg.) (2008): Intensivtraining Produktion, Einkauf, Logistik und Dienstleistung. URL: https://www.springer.com/de/book/9783834910639 (last access: 30.03.2022)

7.1. Quiz - Advantages and Disadvantages of rail


Now that you've looked at all the elements of the rail transport system, here are some quiz questions again for testing your knowledge:
Quiz: Advantages and disadvantages of rail by Prof. Dr.-Ing. Heike Flämig, Katharina Beck, Sandra Tjaden, Patrick Fieltsch(CC BY-SA)

 

 
 

 

 

8. Literature

Academic (2022): Umsprung (Eisenbahnfahrzeug). URL: http://de.academic.ru/dic.nsf/dewiki/1432879 (last access: 30.03.2022).

Allianz pro Schiene e.V. (2019): Güterverkehr-Mehr Verkehr auf die Schiene. URL: https://www.allianz-pro-schiene.de/themen/gueterverkehr/ (last access: 30.03.2022 ).

Bahn-aktuell (2008): Eisenbahnfährhafen Sassnitz/Mukran. URL: http://www.bahn-aktuell.net/Archiv2008/BT/03-14-DB/ (last access: 30.03.2022).

Büker, T. (2018): Maps and facts on european interoperability issues. URL: http://bueker.net/trainspotting/voltage_map_europe.php (last access: 30.03.2022).

Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Bau- und Wohnungswesen (2004): Verkehr in Zahlen 2004/2005. 33. Jahrgang, URL: https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Publikationen/G/verkehr-in-zahlen_2004-pdf.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (last access: 30.03.2022).

Bundesministerium für Verkehr und digitale Infrastruktur (2020): Verkehr in Zahlen 2020/2021. 49. Jahrgang, URL: https://www.bmvi.de/SharedDocs/DE/Publikationen/G/verkehr-in-zahlen-2020-pdf.pdf?__blob=publicationFile (last access: 30.03.2022).

DB Cargo AG (2021): Ganzzugverkehr: Ihre Wahl für große Mengen. URL:  https://www.dbcargo.com/rail-de-de/leistungen/schienentransporte/Ganzzug (last access: 30.03.2022).

DB Netz AG (2016): Seit 2016 verkehren 835 m lange Güterzüge auch aus dem Hamburger Hafen. URL:
https://fahrweg.dbnetze.com/fahrweg-de/kunden/betrieb/laengere_gueterzuege-1393340 (last access: 30.03.2022) 

Deutsche Bahn AG (2019): Rangierbahnhof Maschen. URL: https://www.deutschebahn.com/pr-hamburg-de/DB-im-Norden-1/Regionale-Themen/rbf_maschen-6121248 (last access: 30.03.2022)

Deutscher Bundestag (2019): Gleisanschlüsse im deutschen Bahnnetz. Drucksache19/9305. Antwort der Bundesregierung auf die Kleine Anfrage der Abgeordneten Sabine Leidig, Dr. Gesine Lötzsch, Lorenz Gösta Beutin, weiterer Abgeordneter und der Fraktion DIE LINKE. – Drucksache 19/8731 –. URL: https://dserver.bundestag.de/btd/19/093/1909305.pdf (last access: 30.03.2022). 

Doll, N. (2016): Bahnverbindung Deutschland-China ist eine Erfolgsgeschichte. URL: https://www.welt.de/wirtschaft/article160672317/Bahnverbindung-Deutschland-China-ist-eine-Erfolgsgeschichte.html (last acces: 30.03.2022).

European Commission (2020): EU Transport Figures. Statistical Pocketbook 2020. URL: https://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/da0cd68e-1fdd-11eb-b57e-01aa75ed71a1.0001.03/DOC_1 (last access: 30.03.2022).

Flämig, H., Sjöstedt, L., Hertel, C. (2002): Multimodal Transport: An Integrated Element for Last-Mile-Solutions? Proceedings, part 1; International Congress on Freight Transport Automation and Multimodality: Organisational and Technological Innovations. Delft, 23 & 24 May 2002.  (modification of Sjöstedt 1996)  

Horvath Verlag GmbH (2016): Transsiberian route: DB Cargo remains a partner of BMW. URL: http://www.oevz.com/en/news-en/transsiberian-route-db-cargo-remains-a-partner-of-bmw/ (last access: 30.03.2022).

Lübcke, D., Hecht, M. (2011): Das System Bahn, 2. Auflage, Hamburg.

Lumsden, Kenth R. (2020): Fundamentals of Logistics, Translation of selected chapters of the book “Logistikens Grunder”. Göteborg, August.

Matthews, V. (2007): Bahnbau, 7. Auflage, Wiesbaden.

Nuhn, H.; Hesse, M. (2006): Verkehrsgeographie, Schöningh Verlag, Paderborn.

NYK Logistics Europe Ltd.; Bruun, T.O.; Kühne School (2008): Tagesforum Internationale Transportketten.

Pachl, J. (2013): Systemtechnik des Schienenverkehrs. 7. Auflage. Springer Vieweg Verlag Wiesbaden

Publications Office of the European Union (2016): Directive (EU) 2016/797 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 May 2016 on the interoperability of the rail system within the European Union. URL: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2016/797/oj (last access: 30.03.2022).

Schulte, C. (1991): Logistik. Wege zur Optimierung des Material- und Informationsflusses. Verlag Franz Vahlen, München. 

UBA (2010): Schienennetz 2025/2030-Ausbaukonzeption für einen leistungsfähigen Schienengüterverkehr in Deutschland. URL: https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/sites/default/files/medien/461/publikationen/4005.pdf (last access: 30.03.2022)

Verkehrsrundschau (2008): Deutsche Bahn erprobt erstmals 1000-Meter-Güterzug.
URL: https://www.verkehrsrundschau.de/nachrichten/transport-logistik/deutsche-bahn-erprobt-erstmals-1000-meter-gueterzug-3020883 (last access: 30.03.2022)  

Wannenwetsch, H. (Hrsg.) (2008): Intensivtraining Produktion, Einkauf, Logistik und Dienstleistung. URL: https://www.springer.com/de/book/9783834910639 (last access: 30.03.2022)